RTD or robotaxi: which costs the public less?
Robotaxi prices are just starting to show up, so every assumption here is yours to change. The only fixed inputs are each route's real boardings and estimated cost. The table compares the net public cost of each: bus cost minus bus fares, against robotaxi operator cost minus whatever fare riders pay.
| Route | Boardings | Bus cost / boarding | Robotaxi cost / boarding | RTD net cost | Robotaxi net cost | Verdict | Difference | Cars at rush hour | Break-even $/mi |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| R RidgeGate Parkway Station to Peoria Station | 1,283,393 | $21.96 | $11.99 | $27.2M | $15.4M | Robotaxi | saves $11.8M | $2.21 | 196 |
| D 18th&California Station to Mineral Station | 2,405,236 | $13.60 | $11.99 | $30.8M | $28.8M | Too close | saves $2.0M | $1.34 | 367 |
| E Union Station to RidgeGate Parkway Station | 2,678,789 | $12.94 | $11.99 | $32.6M | $32.1M | Too close | saves $447.7K | $1.27 | 409 |
| W Union Station to Jefferson County Government Center-Golden Station | 3,346,205 | $10.94 | $11.99 | $34.0M | $40.1M | RTD | costs $6.1M | $1.06 | 511 |
Robotaxi cost = boardings × trip length × (1 + empty miles) ÷ riders per vehicle trip × cost per vehicle-mile. Assumptions in this run: $1.25/vehicle-mile, 40% empty miles, 1.0 riders per trip, NTD average trip length, $0.00 rider fare per mile.
Every route uses the same average trip length, so robotaxi cost per boarding is identical across routes. RTD does not publish trip length by route. Riders on long express and regional routes travel further than average: set a trip length to test them.
RTD net cost = estimated route cost × the share you chose to count (100%), minus fares. Robotaxi cost per mile includes the accessible-fleet premium. Break-even is the base operator cost per mile at which both cost the public the same.
Not modelled: traffic and curb space from extra vehicles, whether an operator would serve low-demand areas, and vehicle replacement and debt for buses (not yet transcribed from RTD's financial report).